![]() |
James Smith, fitness influencer (photo credit FB) |
I recently ran across a post by James Smith, a popular fitness influencer, who posts a lot on Facebook, who was asking "are electrolyte products a supplement industry scam?," in this post. His content is generally pretty good. Occasionally parts seem a bit off, but in general most is quite solid, in my opinion.
I think electrolyte products are a scam, that you can easily supplement potassium and magnesium, throughout the day, and typically don't need extra sodium, so they are mostly useless. They are often formulated to contain mostly salt (sodium chloride), and not much potassium and magnesium, and often contain plenty of sugar, and flavoring.
I'm not going to break down James' input, from that video, and focus more on basics here, but parts of it might help with including key points. For example, he said that the main electrolyte supplement he typically takes is 80% glucose (sugar), which of course adds energy input, and probably helps with faster digestion, but it's still a case of drinking sugar water. Coke would work for that. And it's generally better to use complex carbohydrates as a dietary input than sugar, which I won't do much with developing here.
James cited a source saying that if you aren't training for more than four hours you don't need to supplement electrolytes during exercise. Probably running a marathon is a different case; that's not standard exercise, and people can complete those in under 3 hours. That's his conclusion in that post, that people could just drink water with salt in it, and don't need that during the exercise, or just before or after, as those products are marketed.
In looking up the earlier post that prompted me to write about that subject I turned up an intro from Eric Berg. He's a chiropractor, who draws some criticism for passing on vague and general health advise, when he's not even a medical doctor. But most of what he says is basic enough to be reliable; it's only when he moves outside that scope that things might be questionable, like in making health claims about fasting. Here's that summary post by him:
Let's talk about electrolytes—what they are and why you need them. Electrolytes are electrically charged minerals, such as:
• Potassium
• Magnesium
• Sodium
• Chloride
• Calcium
Top causes of an electrolyte deficiency:
• Fasting
• The keto diet
• Sweating
• Vomiting
• Diarrhea
• Diuretics
• A high-carb diet
Electrolytes power the nervous system, muscles, and cells. They also control fluid balance within the cells and outside of the cells. Warning signs of an electrolyte deficiency:
1. Arrhythmias or heart palpitations
2. Fatigue or weakness
3. Dizziness and dehydration
4. High pulse rate
5. Muscle twitching, spasms, or cramps
6. Constipation
7. Headaches and brain swelling
8. Shock
9. Nausea or keto flu
10. Decreased blood clotting
Dr. Eric Berg, DC, not MD
Sounds about right. I've experienced some of that while fasting, which was my intro to looking into this subject. After three days, with no electrolyte supplementation, I experienced energy level disruption, muscle cramping, and at least perceived irregular heartbeat. Of course I ended that fast.
Here's another post image from him that adds to why he might be criticized:
That's generally accepted as a myth now. Here's Gemini's AI input on how that works out:
Himalayan salt (often sold as "Himalayan sea salt," though it is mined rock salt from ancient sea beds) is typically 95% to 99% sodium chloride, with the remaining 1% to 5% made up of sulfates and trace minerals.
Main and Trace Minerals
• Sodium and Chloride: Make up the vast majority of the salt, similar to regular table salt (roughly 2,200 mg of sodium per teaspoon).
• Commonly Detected Minerals: Calcium, potassium, magnesium, iron (which gives the salt its pink tint via iron oxide), and sulfates.
In Himalayan pink salt, potassium typically makes up about 0.2% to 0.45% of the salt by weight, while magnesium generally accounts for 0.015% to 0.27%.
So you would use Himalayan sea salt to supplement sodium, but nothing else, in functional amounts. It does not "enhance hydration," any more than table salt would. Unless those sulfates cause that, but come on.
Electrolyte basics
Fasting is what led to me exploring this issue, not running in very hot weather, as I routinely do in Bangkok (and some in Honolulu, when I'm there, but it's cooler). It's discussed a lot in a fasting sub on Reddit, r/fasting, as in this general discussion thread. No consensus ever emerges; people see the issue in different ways, and take up different practices. Probably individual requirements also vary.
It's an awkward theme, but I want to be clear that it's very difficult to determine how much electrolytes you require when you fast, versus ordinarily, or how exercise demands influence how much more of different electrolytes you should be ingesting.
I can't unpack this as even loose and general guidance. I've seen claims in fasting groups that your proportion of sodium to potassium required is vastly different than in normal circumstances, but it's hard to accept that as well-supported without doing a lot of research, and I haven't.
What we can easily do is review a standard input guidance baseline, and then make some adjustment for special circumstances (fasting, in hot weather, when exercising a lot, etc.). Any reference source will list the same general range, as this does, from here:
It's interesting that the Gemini AI input is slightly different:
|
Electrolyte |
Typical Daily Dietary Target |
Primary Dietary Sources |
|
Sodium |
~1,500–2,300
mg/day |
Table salt, savory
foods, broths |
|
Potassium |
~2,600 mg/day
(women); ~3,400 mg/day (men) |
Bananas, citrus,
potatoes, leafy greens, legumes |
|
Chloride |
~2,300 mg/day |
Table salt (sodium
chloride) |
|
Calcium |
~1,000–1,200
mg/day |
Dairy products,
fortified tofu, leafy greens |
|
Magnesium |
~310–320 mg/day
(women); ~400–420 mg/day (men) |
Nuts, seeds, whole
grains, spinach |
Other references cite an optimum intake in relation to body weight as a factor; maybe that's more accurate.
James Smith mentioned that it's normal for many people to ingest three grams of salt a day, more than required, which raises an interesting point right away. Salt is sodium chloride; eating three grams of sodium chloride (NaCl) relates to intake of 1.18 grams of sodium. That's already probably enough, for most people, even though it's below the range cited in those tables, but this is often being discussed in relation to doing a lot of daily exercise as an input, which changes things.
That would relate to 1.82 grams of chloride intake, of course, so you would mostly be covered on that separate electrolyte requirement.
Electrolyte supplementation related to fasting
In fasting circles it's accepted that your body mostly needs to supplement sodium, magnesium, and potassium during a fast, and not the others. This is generally regarded as not necessary for fasts up to two days in duration; for three days or longer people might add this input, and at 5 to 7 days it becomes critical (per my take, at least).
How can we know if that works, if the others would generally be required in lower amounts at that time, or if they are readily available through reserve sources, if this isn't the case? From extensive research again, I guess. In the end people seem to go with what works, and for most that's moderate supplementation of only those three electrolytes, even for people fasting for more than a week (per online discussion input, which of course is just hearsay).
Just from scanning through those numbers it makes you wonder if a standard diet really is providing 2 or 3 grams of potassium a day. Are you eating a lot of bananas, citrus, potatoes, leafy greens, and legumes? I typically eat one banana with breakfast, and eggs with spinach or some other green, but then that relates to considering this concern.
![]() |
sharing eggs at breakfast with Marmalade |
That breakfast theme reminds me, tea does contain some minerals, although I wouldn't count on it to resolve electrolyte balance. Gemini says this:
When you fast that works out to be an awful lot of salt (the amounts listed in the past section, but during fasting requirements may drop a little). Consider this:
2 grams (2,000 mg) of sodium equals about 5 grams of table salt, or roughly 1 teaspoon
It might seem like you could mix a teaspoon of salt into a large glass of water, and drink that down, but from fasting experience you might end up gagging that down instead. Then there is the potassium to consider:
It takes approximately 3.81 grams (3,813 milligrams) of potassium chloride (KCl) to provide 2 grams of elemental potassium.
When fasting you realize that if you ingest a lot of any electrolyte at one time it acts as a laxative, so anyone drinking down those 8.81 grams of salts at one time, mixed into water, would head straight to the bathroom in minutes, even if they hadn't eaten in days. Your body keeps releasing some digestive fluids to process in your digestive system, so you can't have normal bowel movements under those circumstances, but you do experience some vaguely related activity. I'll spare the details here.
Back to electrolyte input related to exercise, or eating a poor diet
Where does this leave us related to exercise related daily inputs? You need a good bit of sodium and potassium, and a very healthy diet probably already includes that. An unhealthy diet is probably even higher in sodium, so as long as you are eating some McDonald's food or potato chips you're fine, for sodium. You might want to top up potassium a bit, if your diet seems questionable.
Related to supplementation magnesium is even easier. That daily range is 300 to 400 mg, not the teaspoons worth of the others. Lots of people in fasting circles claim that some magnesium compounds act more as a laxative, so even in those moderate amounts if they take the wrong version they have problems with that. I can take a magnesium tablet of different types and notice no effect; I've checked that through trial and error. So even when I'm not fasting I take on magnesium tablet a day and I'm covered. Just now I'm taking 400 mg per day as magnesium oxide.
If I ended up eating a well-balanced diet, including plenty of nuts, seeds, whole grains, spinach, it's quite possible that I'm doubling my required intake of magnesium, and my kidneys need to do a little extra work to filter that back out. It's a light burden, compared to overshooting sodium by a gram or so, which could easily happen. I don't eat a lot of chips and such but I do have a small back of Cheetos on hand, and one serving, 30 gram, contains 180 mg of sodium. It would take 10 servings to add up to a daily supply; not bad. But then I'm in Thailand just now; I wonder if the level is different in the US, if even that specific product varies?
This seems a reasonable place to add what an electrolyte drink might include. My son has been drinking a "Liquid IV" brand version, for who knows what reason. One "stick," 16 grams, includes 500 mg of sodium, 380 mg of potassium, no magnesium, and 45 calories (as cane sugar and dextrose). It also includes Vitamin C, Niacin, B6 and B12. Is that good?
His diet is pretty inconsistent, so it's probably helpful for him, because sometimes he's just not eating that much, and he definitely never eats much for vegetables and fruit. He eats essentially no nuts, seeds, whole grains, or spinach, so his magnesium intake might be limited, which that product isn't helping with.
Their claim, on that product packaging, is that you digest water faster when you drink it along with electrolytes (and sugar, I guess), which could work, but it kind of doesn't matter. Your body digests plain water relatively quickly and easily. It's implied that you can drink less water if you add electrolytes, that it acts as some sort of multiplier, which of course isn't accurate. They don't actually say that, because it's not true, but it's still used as a vague selling point.
In that content that I mentioned James Smith already concluded, in reference to multiple studies, that most people don't need to supplement any of this just before or after exercise, unless they are working out for four hours or more. Who does that?
I would hike for longer, and still might sometimes, back in Hawaii, but that's generally moderate intensity, even if some elevation change is involved. I would do long hikes in the desert when I was young, in Utah and Arizona, hiking for 8 to 10 hours in temperatures well over 100 F (40+ C). I seemed fine, but I ate hearty food before and after hiking, and ate a basic trail mix out there, usually something like nuts and raisins. I probably craved salty snacks and foods, and ate them, without giving it much thought.
So it seems like there's plenty to consider related to special requirements (fasting, exercise, and heat stress exposure), and that dialing in optimum intake would be tricky. But bumping those main electrolyte levels wouldn't be so difficult, if there seems to be a special demand.
I use a potassium and sodium salt mix substitute, instead of salt, to balance back out potassium intake. Beyond that I usually eat one banana a day, include plenty of mixed greens in my diet (not so much lettuce; I mean others), and that magnesium tablet cover the rest. I use mixed nuts as a snack; that might top up sodium input, and add a little protein, healthy fat, and some other nutrients.
What minerals are lost in sweat?
I do run for about an hour at a time, often in high heat conditions, here where I usually live in Bangkok. For sure I'm sweating out plenty of electrolytes, bumping those baseline requirements slightly, or maybe a good bit. What is the proportion of electrolytes lost in sweat, one might wonder? Google thinks it knows.
![]() |
where I run in Bangkok, in the evening. it's still hot, but it feels cooler. |
Electrolytes are the main minerals lost during a run, with concentrations varying widely depending on genetics, fitness level, and heat acclimatization.
• Sodium and Chloride. Together, these form common salt and account for the vast majority of mineral loss. An athlete typically loses 460 to 1,840 mg of sodium per liter of sweat, which leaves behind the white, crusty residue seen on skin and hats after long runs.
• Potassium. Lost in much smaller amounts than sodium, typically around 4 to 8 mmol/L.
• Calcium and Magnesium. Present only in trace quantities, usually under 1.0 mmol/L
So that theme of bumping sodium intake during exercise isn't really ungrounded. I've seen other studies on the mineral content of sweat in r/running, on Reddit, but that's not easy to turn up again. It would vary anyway.
The main assertion here is that identifying and balancing electrolyte input isn't that difficult, and that as I see it there would be no reason to add that input just before or after exercise. It's better to keep your levels where they should be all of the time, and overshooting by a little isn't a problem. Eating way too much salt could be a problem, so it would be good to get a feel for what an overall diet input is related to all of these main electrolytes.
![]() |
one place I run in Hawaii, around Diamondhead |
![]() |
later in that same run, out and back the Ala Wai canal |







No comments:
Post a Comment