I'm reviewing two random oolong samples from Moychay, a Nong Xiang Tie Guan Yin and Longjuan Meizhan Oolong. Pretty much only TGY means much to me; I'll cite their descriptions to explain what these are.
Flame Tie Guanyin Oolong Tea (Nong Xiang Tie Guanyin) (60 grams for $23.36)
Origin: China · Fujian · Sanming, Around 1,300 m · handpicked
Nong Xiang Tie Guan Yin · deeply baked · traditional processing
A traditional deeply baked Tie Guan Yin with a rich and warming character. Roasted fruit and honey meet persistent orchid notes and smooth minerality.
The body is full and rounded, followed by a long, sweet finish. The liquor is clear amber-red. Main taste notes: Roasted · Orchid · Honey...
The intensive baking transforms the greener character of Tie Guan Yin into a warmer profile of baked fruit, honey, orchid and mineral notes.
Longjuan Wild High Mountain Meizhan Oolong Tea , 7g (only available as 7 grams for $5)
Longjuan Yesheng Gaoshan Meizhan Youji Wulong Cha (2024)
Meizhan is a traditional Chinese oolong tea from Anxi County, Quanzhou City, Fujian Province. Grown at altitudes between 500 and 800 meters, this tea is hand-picked during two main harvest seasons: mid-April to mid-May and mid-September to mid-October. The plucking standard is one bud with three leaves, and only manually harvested leaves are used...
When brewed, Meizhan offers a floral and toasty aroma, with a balanced, rich, and smooth taste profile.
What is Meizhan though, a tea style, cultivar, or something else? Google AI weighs in:
Meizhan (梅占, or "Plum Blossom") is a versatile and robust tea cultivar from China primarily processed into oolong, though it is also adapted for black or white teas.
• Origin: Native to southern Fujian Province (Anxi County), Meizhan has also been widely planted in the Wuyi Mountains (Wuyishan) since the 1960s to produce rock oolong (yancha).
• The Bush: Often called "tall stem" or "big leaf" Meizhan, the plant grows into a tall tree-like bush with a distinct trunk and thick, leathery, elongated leaves. It is one of the earliest sprouting cultivars in the spring.
Note that primary references it is citing are credited there (Rivers and Lakes Tea, Tea and Whisk, and Nannuoshan's Youtube content). That's not offering so much source credit, but at least it's a start.
So it's really a plant type. Probably not necessarily a cultivar, in the strictest sense, since that's usually intended as meaning only a plant type with controlled genetic character, like a Taiwanese hybrid. Older, broader plant types, like Qing Xin in Taiwan, or Rou Gui in Wuyishan, would vary quite a bit, as genetics drift over time. It still generally means "plant type," I'm just making that clearer.
On to how the tasting notes relate to all of that.
Review:
Tie Guan Yin: just getting started. This is really promising though; the roast input comes across nicely, in a novel form. There's a root beer sort of sweetness and depth to this. It should be good, but I'll add more flavor list next round.
Longjuan Wild High Mountain Meizhan: also slow to fully infuse, but faster, related to this being open strip form oolong, and also very promising. Warm roasted tones stand out in this, in a different kind of way. This tastes like really nice Wuyi Yancha can, when deep floral range is brought out by roasting, instead of masking and replacing it. One part inclines towards spice, not so far off cinnamon, just not exactly that. It has great mineral range and depth, and a touch of brandy or liqueur like aromatic range, which is both pleasant and a good indicator of quality.
For some tea versions I might struggle to place just how good a tea is, or how limited quality or positive aspects are, when one really doesn't stand out. These stand out.
Tie Guan Yin #2: I infused this a little longer than the other, to account for the form difference, and it needing to open up. Not long though; the other I brewed for 10 seconds or less, and this for not much over 10, maybe 15. It's good. There's always the question of why traditional style, more oxidized, and well-balanced roast input form Tie Guan Yin are rare, with the bright and light versions most of what you see (nuclear yellow, a favorite old blog reference would call that, Marshal N of Tea Addict's Journal).
This isn't exactly that older and better balanced style. Roast level is high but oxidation input is probably limited, with more on that to follow.
It's good, but the other version is probably going to make it sound more limited than it actually is, for being so positive and novel. It tastes like TGY, that characteristic floral flavor (which some could peg to actual flower types), just warmed and changed through more oxidation and roast input.
Warm, inky tones are a balanced part of the rest. I suppose it could be even better with very well integrated additional oxidation, which would sweeten and warm the flavor in a different way. But it's good. Often higher roast will seem to cover a flaw in a tea, for example to mask when a version is really a year or two old, and is getting a bit stale, but these results are so positive this could be an intentional optimization of leaf potential instead (or an attempt at it; it would be hard to plan for and identify a perfect outcome). I'll try to break down the aspects more as a list as I go.
Longjuan Meizhan: there is no familiar flavor profile or style to this. I've compared it to Wuyi Yancha, but it's not a close match to the main conventional types of that, even though Wuyi Yancha covers a very broad range of plant types, terroir inputs, and processing styles, so it would be hard to say what couldn't be represented there.
The combination of spice input with unique floral range is different, and this oxidation input balanced really well with the rest. It's probably roasted, but you can't identify the inky and heavy input as with the other, a more conventional form. It at least seems like oxidation input has caused the main transition, and roast input is light, and secondary, supporting that.
Feel is nice, but it could be a little thicker. Aftertaste carry-over is positive too, but that could also be stronger. Interesting and positive flavor is the high point of this tea version, which is a nice thing to experience. Warm mineral base input works, balancing the rest, in a positive and subtle way. It's all balanced, and to an extent refined, which is a concept or term I use to express that lots of subtle aspects fall together in a very well integrated way. The other tea version hits a few levels and notes pretty hard, which does balance, but this ties together a half dozen more subtle inputs. For a sheng pu'er drinker maybe intensity is limited, but then tea character blasting you is more of a sheng thing.
TGY #3: it's still quite pleasant. I suppose this is an example of a more roasted but lighter oxidation input TGY, not the older and differently balanced style. But it works. Just adding lots of roast to a flawed or limited light version doesn't get you this kind of result. There's a good bit of floral range, an inky minerality, and a hinting towards spice. Feel is full enough, and there's some aftertaste carry-over. If someone was promoting this as some next-level, 80 cent a gram quality range version I wouldn't buy that, but it's a pretty solid tea. Those inputs balance and integrate fairly well. There are probably plenty of people who would absolutely love this style and character outcome, then others who wouldn't.
Longjuan Meizhan: it's interesting how those different flavor inputs balance, and shift from round to round. This now tastes like a different bark spice than cinnamon, a range of themes I was more familiar with in my 30s when I drank a lot of tisanes. I think people would unpack a flavor list in vastly different ways, so even though it is complex, balanced, and integrated there probably wouldn't be much agreement on what flavors are going into that. That would be challenging related to creating a vendor description.
This is from 2024, so it has settled a bit already, and that wouldn't completely shift flavor but it might let it integrate in a different way than initially. Roast input could soften over time, but this doesn't seem to have been heavily roasted anyway.
The feel effect is different in both. You might expect that this kind of aspect range is a good way to distinguish a difference between these teas, and to describe both better. The first version has a conventional fullness--moderate in intensity, not pronounced--that is common to rolled oolongs in general, and this version is harder to describe. It's not astringent; there is no roughness, and it doesn't come across as a structured feel. But it's that little bit towards that, from typical oolong fullness, more impactful in feel, just not rough or dry.
TGY #4: these teas are far from fading away but I'll still do one longer infusion round (20 seconds or so) and stop taking notes; this runs long enough, and they're not transitioning that much. It's as positive as it has been. That set of aspects balances well, the warm tones, mineral, hint of spice, and warm floral range. It's interesting how as a list it sounds like the other tea, but in actual experience it's all fairly different. The tones within those categories aren't the same, and the general effect is different. Maybe for some they would seem almost the same, but to me they're not.
The base of this experience is a somewhat greener Tie Guan Yin input, with that distinctive floral range. After the roasting input it comes across as deeper and broader floral tone, lets say including lavender instead of just lighter tones, that I'm not good at placing. Let's ask AI what it thinks:
Tie Guan Yin oolong tea most commonly tastes and smells like fresh orchid flowers.
Depending on the specific style and how it is processed, the floral notes can also feature other delicate characteristics:
• Orchid: The signature and most famous floral note associated with the Tie Guan Yin Oolong cultivar.
• Gardenia: Lightly oxidized, modern green-style versions can offer bright, dewy gardenia and spring floral aromas.
• Osmanthus or subtle sweet florals: Traditional roasted styles soften the sharp floral bouquet into a warmer, toasty, and creamy sweetness with faint fruity undertones.
I could kind of see the orchid but that doesn't sound right, even though there are lots of orchid types, and osmanthus is also close but maybe not that.
Longjuan Meizhan: like it was last time. Maybe it picked up a little depth and complexity, or maybe not.
Where the other tea includes 3 or 4 main flavor inputs that balance this comes across as a complex and well-integrated broad range of flavor. People could describe it differently, since it's hard to describe. To me a bark spice flavor is central, not cinnamon though. Floral range might be next, and it also leans towards or includes rich dried fruit range, like tamarind, perhaps with a touch of citrus zest. Aromatic tones are even harder to isolate. It might include something along the line of vanilla. There's a touch of creamy effect, that could be interpreted as relating to a caramel sweetness input. There's a lot going on, but it comes across as a broad and integrated range.
I suppose I like the second version better, and see it as a more novel and higher quality level tea. It's approachable; there isn't much to it that I would expect some people wouldn't like. But it's nothing like a conventional more oxidized oolong version, like a rolled "red" oolong, even though it's kind of along a similar line in some ways.















