This reviews two black teas from a set of samples sent by Moychay for review (many thanks!). Dian Hong is my overall favorite black tea, so I expected that to really stand out, at least related to match to preference.
It turned out both are pretty good, in different style scope. I'll cite the vendor descriptions first and then go straight to the review, since I don't have much to add about prior exposure to Mei Zhan. I did just review an oolong made from that cultivar, here; that says a little about what that is.
Black Tea Mei Zhan Hong Cha, Chinese tea (Red Tea), 70g ($26.45 for 70 grams)
Mei Zhan Black Tea originates from Fenglin Village, Shuyang Town, Nanjing County, Fujian Province. The Mei Zhan tea tree, also known as Da Ye Mei Zhan or Gao Jiao Oolong, is a semi-arbor, medium-leaf, and medium-bud variety. Known for its distinctive orchid aroma and full-bodied flavor, Mei Zhan tea is well-suited for producing both black and green teas.
The tea gardens are situated at an altitude of 900–950 meters, benefiting from the area’s clean air and rich soil...
The brewed tea yields a bright amber infusion with a rich orchid aroma and a smooth, full-bodied flavor. The taste is both refreshing and complex, with a lingering sweetness that develops across multiple infusions.
It started out quite tart, and that evolved away after a couple of rounds, so positive transition was a big part of this tea experience.
Black Tea GAOSHAN DIAN HONG CHA, Chinese tea from High Mountain in Yunnan Province (Red Tea) (only a 7 gram sample is now available, for $1.19, but 90 grams had been just under $10)
Dian Hong, or Yunnan Red Tea, is produced in Fengqing County, Yunnan Province, a region known for its ideal tea-growing conditions. With abundant sunshine, high altitudes, and significant day-night temperature differences, the region provides an exceptional environment for cultivating high-quality tea. This tea is made from the Mengku Da Ye Zhong cultivar, known for its bold and robust character.
The tea is grown at elevations of 1800–2200 meters and is hand-picked during the spring harvest (March 25 to April 15)...
Dian Hong brews into a bright red infusion with a rich, layered aroma combining honey, fruit, and floral notes. The taste is smooth and full-bodied, with a sweet, lingering aftertaste and a slight hint of bitterness that balances the flavor. The tea’s complex and refined profile evolves beautifully over multiple infusions.
I could imagine different people with different preferences preferring either of these. Dian Hong being my favorite black / red tea definitely added some type bias, but the other was nice in a different way. For this Dian Hong costing this much less it seems a much better value, but then I could see why some parts of the character / aspect range could be regarded as less positive, and supply and demand issues also determines the final cost for different tea versions.
For samples packaged awhile ago, two years in this case, how well they'll hold up depends on packaging material and how suitable the tea is for aging. These are fine, related to both. They've probably traded out a bit of the brighter, more aromatic range for depth, but black teas can even improve with age, depending on the starting point aspects.
Review:
Mei Zhan first infusion: pretty much how I expected this to be: sweet, a bit tart, complex, and fruity. It tastes like roselle or cranberry, given that fruitiness that includes sweetness. For some this could be a personal favorite black tea type, but in general I like tart versions of black tea the least. You can tell this is pretty good though, as quality level and balanced character go. Nice mineral supports the rest, and the flavor is complex and full, without much for negative aspect range, unless you find the tartness objectionable. I'll do more of a flavor list the next round.
This was brewed a bit strong. I didn't brew these for that long, maybe 20 seconds, but they're fairly intense teas, it seems, so using faster rounds will be better, at least early on.
Gaoshan Dian Hong: it's funny how this is the opposite of the other in a few ways. The forward blast of higher end range flavor has been replaced by a lot of depth, with decent balance across the rest of the range, but it's still mostly rich and deep. Turning around what I've already said, while this is a personal favorite style for me others could see that as a limitation, or even a flaw. It's funny how personal preference works out.
There's a pleasant fruit note in this that's hard to place. It's close enough to Chinese date; we could just go with that for now. It has a bit of cacao but that doesn't stand out, as it often can. Other warm tones would require some unpacking, whether those are spice notes, leather, or whatever else. There's a nice warm mineral base, giving it the effect of depth. It would be natural for people to interpret this as including roasted yam or sweet potato, even as a primary flavor component. It's definitely at least part of the list.
There is a faint hint of tartness in this. I might interpret that as stronger without the first including ten times as much of that input. It's funny how these tastings can throw off relative expectations. Two sweet teas can make the sweetness just seem normal, or one like that and one not can really emphasize the difference. Going back to try the first after this really shocks your palate. It seems to include a bit of complex spice as well; I'll try to unpack that more as I go.
Mei Zhan #2: I brewed these for about 10 seconds, kind of fast, so this is on the light side instead this time. Sometimes that can help with unpacking flavors better, even if it's not an optimum balance for pleasantness.
Sweetness is fine in this; there's a sort of browned caramel taste that seems to be part of that. Tartness eased up. More depth comes out, as it expresses more range in general. The fruit effect moves off just being cranberry, or roselle, a Thai herb used as a tisane that tastes a bit like cranberry. It's a bit broad to clearly interpret. The spice note stood out more in contrast with the other tea than it does trying this now. Maybe it will pick up again later. Mineral depth is fine; this works.
Dian Hong: that's exceptional. I think the part that puts it over the edge from just being good is the match to what I like in tea. Dian Hong is my favorite black tea type, and this version's character matches parts of what I like well. It's the same list as last time, even though the overall balance of how those parts come together is shifting. The cacao note is more pronounced, and that leans a little towards a rich leather flavor. The mineral is richer and deeper. Sweetness is good, but someone could definitely interpret this as missing some forward flavor range, and not being balanced. To me it's such a familiar style that I don't see it that way; it's just how Dian Hong often are. Old plant material as an input can exaggerate that, trading out some brighter, more forward flavors for depth.
In going back and trying the first after this again fruit stands out more this time. That's in between the brighter, tart cranberry and something like Chinese date, ju-jube, which this second tea expressed more of in the first round. It's interesting that they echo each other a little. Mixing the last of both kind of works, but in general I don't drink teas like that, all muddled together and rounded off, trading distinctiveness for balance. But it was natural to check and see.
Mei Zhan #3: the most balanced and positive this has been. Spice starts coming out as cinnamon; that's pleasant. The fruit warms in tone, and tartness has really faded to a moderate level. It seemed this could improve over rounds but this really shifted in an overwhelmingly positive way. I'll have to leave off after this, since I again have two or three errands to run (it's Saturday), but this probably has a couple more positive transitions to go. This really seems like a Christmas themed tea, since it now combines cacao, warm fruit (more toward dark cherry now), and cinnamon. I might like it more than the other at this stage.
Dian Hong: I suppose that I still like this more, but it's working within a much narrower flavor profile. I just love this depth, and the flavor range works especially well for me. It still seems to express a little more rich fruit than roasted yam (I think it's yam, more than sweet potato), but I suppose that's a judgment call. Both of these express a caramel or toffee range sweetness. These would both be fantastic fall teas, or would even match well with a Christmas holiday theme.
The depth includes a rich, full feel. Even though that initial hit of forward flavor is more limited than in the other it includes a lot of fruit and warm toned oriented aftertaste, giving it the impression of conveying a full experience. These are both better than I expected. This one is normal for this range, but it all hangs together really well. The depth is greater than expected, and fullness of feel and aftertaste expression. It's transitioning in overall balance instead of shifting in form, like the other. Both experiences are interesting.
This sounds a little like some sort of marketing spin, doesn't it? No mention of limitations (beyond initially saying that I don't like tartness), playing up depth and complexity, etc. To me it's just what I think of these teas. I've described lots of the Moychay sample range I've reviewed as much closer to ordinary, with a lot more limitations. That's how it can go with these market-style vendors, especially related to cost being all over the place. Value varies too, and how good the teas are. These are pretty solid.
Later rounds: both of these just kept going. I'll usually share a very late infusion with my daughter's plant, so it can drink tea too, but these kept on as so positive I drank round after round of both, never giving that plant its share this time, as I remember.
Conclusions:
I can see why different people might like either more, depending on their preferences. The early tartness aspect in the Mei Zhan based version was a little negative, for me, but that faded pretty fast, and the later infusions were all positive in different ways, with it continuing to transition through lots of rounds. The Dian Hong stayed more consistent, not changing, but I like that particular tea character, in the form that expressed.
They were both really solid teas. With the Dian Hong sold out except for samples that's not as helpful, but anyone ordering some around now anyway should include a couple of those, given how good this is, and how good a value it is. Finding moderate cost Dian Hong isn't unusual, but they're usually not this well balanced and positive.





No comments:
Post a Comment